
Yes, friends. Vest #1 on my Vest Quest is in the books! And it will forever be known as the one where I . . . f-ed around and found out.
It’s a snappy little vest, sure, and I will wear it (probably most often with a jacket over it), but I’m not thrilled with it . . . in the end. And, of course, it’s not even close to the Liz-vest I really want to make (which I knew going into the project). But I am on a Vest Quest, and I had to start somewhere!

I actually have MUCH to say about this vest and this yarn and what I “found out” . . . and you can find ALL of that in my project Field Note here. You can also see more photos. And maybe someday I’ll even add it to my Ravelry notebook (but don’t hold your breath).
==========
How about YOU? What are you working on this week?

I like it, Kym, very much. Reminds me of a couple of vests I made for my MIL many years ago. I need to look at my very old vest patterns and see if I can find a vest that is closer to the Liz-vest. I am making preparations for Thanksgiving. I have much to do.
I actually think it’s a great vest — and the pooling isn’t what catches your eye (the cable is). But it’s not Liz yet.
You have a vest you can wear to stay warm all winter. The cable detail looks cool peeking out of the jacket neck and the pooling really won’t show and is less obvious than you think. The vest looks fun and warm!
I’ll finish my fourth vest this week and I LOVE having that warm layer under my jacket or coat. As you know I am always cold and the vest makes my comfort level feel closer to normal. Boy, do I remember the days of vaguely knitting my way through a pattern. Back then I think many people already knew how to knit all.the.stuff, but being a newbee made some knitting trial and error. Oh well, now I am a knitting that “knows” (at 76 yo). lol
The garter edge vest is not vague. The step by step instructions are perfect and I am now to the point (my third vest) where I can breeze (almost) right through. I just finished the neck and armhole detail and it’s smooth sailing this week. Enjoy the warmth and the joy of a layer that makes all the difference in winter. xo
I like the vest, but I can see why you’re not a fan of the pooling and the bleeding. It will keep you warmer, and I hope the next vest in your quest is more like Liz’s and more to your liking!
I went to read all the notes, and I have to say that for all the issues, it does look great on you and like a very wearable piece, even if it’s not the vest of your dreams. Sometimes, though, the failures can give us just as much (if not more) information as the successes, so I know the next attempt will be well informed.
I was confused for a minute… this must be knit top-down? I thought that was dappled sunlight near the bottom. haha. It’s never too late to rip & redo!!